Sorry, can't write a detailed review right now, so here is my very short review of 3 Idiots -
3 Idiots has some genuine funny moments, but overall the film is very illogical. The main problem of the film is the writing. Though the dialogs were good, but the script as a whole was nothing but illogical. Hirani got confused on how much the film should be according to his Munnabhai reputation and how much of it should be Five Point Someone. In the end he makes a film which is a bit of Munnabhai and a bit of Five Point Someone. Hirani yet again tries to do a Hrishikesh Mukherjee but ends up making a David Dhawan kind of film .Tries to make Bawarchi but ends up making Hero No. 1.
Aamir Khan yet again disappoints. Does well in senti moments, but overacts in trying to show that he is still young and cool. Maddy, Sharman and Kareena were very good, but Boman Irani was the best IMO.
6/10
Thanks for your review, Cauli. A short one, ok, not so short one :P, but gave a good idea about what to expect. I guess people go for entertainment to movies, no matter what people would like you to believe, and this one seems to provide that.
ReplyDeleteAnother winner from Aamir.
Shetty's review of 3 Idiots
ReplyDelete3 Idiots Review – Total Garbage
If you take a crappy Indian novel like Five Point Someone and pee all over it, is it any surprise that the end result should turn out to be a piece of mutated trash called 3 Idiots.
And to those of you who mindlessly blabber that 3 Idiots has nothing to do with Five Point Someone, we say: Baby, time you dusted off the cobwebs from your brain.
Read rest from the link
One user review that I loved, agree with it or not, it was hilarious, one of the biggest thing for me in a review is interestingness, it has this.
Didn't ask Shetty for his approval, but whatever I don't care whether he lets me or not :P
Waiting for his MNIK review already :D